Skip to main content
Hélder Raposo
    Apreciação ética de projectos de investigação em saúde: uma reflexão situada a propósito da ética de investigação em ciências sociais 1 Hélder Raposo 2 Resumo: Tomando como ponto de partida uma experiência de colaboração numa comissão de... more
    Apreciação ética de projectos de investigação em saúde: uma reflexão situada a propósito da ética de investigação em ciências sociais 1 Hélder Raposo 2 Resumo: Tomando como ponto de partida uma experiência de colaboração numa comissão de ética de saúde, a presente proposta procura constituir-se como um exercício reflexivo sobre o percurso de participação decorrente do vínculo formal a uma estrutura desta natureza. No entanto, mais do que apenas apresentar um testemunho pessoal que ponha em evidência a visão de um sociólogo relativamente à integração e participação num órgão colegial e multidisciplinar orientado para as questões da saúde, ensaio um exercício analítico orientado para a compreensão e discussão das particularidades do papel e da acção desta estrutura em matéria de apreciação e deliberação ética de projectos de investigação. Palavras-chave: Comissões de ética, multidisciplinariedade, investigação em saúde, ciências sociais. Ethical appraisal of health research projects: A situated reflection on the ethics of research in the social sciences Abstract: Taking as its starting point a collaborative experience in health ethics committee, this proposal aims to establish itself as a reflexive exercise about the formal participation in this kind of structure. However, more than just present a personal testimony that highlights the vision of a sociologist regarding his integration and participation in a collegiate and multidisciplinary body that is oriented to health issues, I develop an analytical exercise oriented to understanding and discussing the particularities of the role of this structure in terms of appreciation and ethical deliberation of research projects.
    Download (.pdf)
    Research Interests:
    Download (.pdf)
    This article analyses performance consumptions among young people. The theme is explored along two main axes. The first concerns the social heterogeneity in this field, considered on two levels: the different purposes for those... more
    This article analyses performance consumptions among young people. The theme is explored along two main axes. The first concerns the social heterogeneity in this field, considered on two levels: the different purposes for those investments - cognitive/mental and physical performance; and the different social contexts - university and work - where performance practices and dispositions may be fostered. The second axis explores the roles of pharmacological and natural consumptions, and their interrelationship, in the dissemination of these practices. The empirical data for this analysis were drawn from an ongoing research project on performance consumptions among young people (aged 18-29years) in Portugal, including both university students and young workers without university education. The results correspond to the stage of extensive research, for which a questionnaire was organised at a national level, using non-proportional quota sampling. On the one hand, they show that (a) there is a hierarchy of acceptance of consumptions according to their purposes, with cognitive/mental performance showing higher acceptance and (b) both pharmaceuticals and natural products are consumed for every type of performance investment. On the other, the comparison between students and workers introduces a certain heterogeneity in this general backdrop, both in terms of the purposes for their consumptions and their opting for natural or pharmacological resources. These threads of heterogeneity will prompt a discussion of the dynamics of pharmaceuticalisation within the field of performance, in particular how therapeutic cultures may be changing in terms of the way individuals relate to medications, expanding their uses in social life.
    Research Interests:
    Download (.pdf)
    Neste artigo identificam-se os padrões de consumo terapêutico na população portuguesa, visando dar conta de um novo padrão emergente nas sociedades modernas, aqui designado de Pluralismo Terapêutico, noção com a qual se categoriza o uso... more
    Neste artigo identificam-se os padrões de consumo terapêutico na população portuguesa, visando dar conta de um novo padrão emergente nas sociedades modernas, aqui designado de Pluralismo Terapêutico, noção com a qual se categoriza o uso conjugado ou alternado de recursos farmacológicos e naturais nas trajetórias terapêuticas dos indivíduos. O respetivo suporte empírico decorre de uma investigação, já concluída, que teve por base uma amostra nacional representativa. Os resultados mostram uma dualização dos consumos terapêuticos que é constituída por um padrão dominante de Farmacologismo – i.e., uso exclusivo de fármacos – coexistente com uma tendência crescente de pluralismo terapêutico. O efeito das fontes de informação terapêutica e dos seus usos leigos, bem como das perceções sociais de risco sobre o natural e o farmacológico, constitui neste estudo uma referência analítica central para a interpretação dos padrões encontrados.
    Research Interests:
    Download (.pdf)
    BACKGROUNDHereditary nonpolyposis colorectal carcinoma (HNPCC) significantly raises the risk of developing colorectal carcinoma (CRC) and other extracolonic tumors. It is defined by the Amsterdam Criteria and is associated with germline... more
    BACKGROUNDHereditary nonpolyposis colorectal carcinoma (HNPCC) significantly raises the risk of developing colorectal carcinoma (CRC) and other extracolonic tumors. It is defined by the Amsterdam Criteria and is associated with germline mutations in mismatch repair genes, primarily MLH1 and MSH2. The objectives of the current study were to evaluate the presence of CRC (Type I) and other extracolonic tumors (Type II) in families with HNPCC and to analyze the findings for correlations with germline mutations in the MLH1 and MSH2 genes.Hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal carcinoma (HNPCC) significantly raises the risk of developing colorectal carcinoma (CRC) and other extracolonic tumors. It is defined by the Amsterdam Criteria and is associated with germline mutations in mismatch repair genes, primarily MLH1 and MSH2. The objectives of the current study were to evaluate the presence of CRC (Type I) and other extracolonic tumors (Type II) in families with HNPCC and to analyze the findings for correlations with germline mutations in the MLH1 and MSH2 genes.METHODSSeventy families with an HNPCC diagnosis were analyzed. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis and direct sequencing were used for germline mutation analysis in the MLH1 and MSH2 genes.Seventy families with an HNPCC diagnosis were analyzed. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis and direct sequencing were used for germline mutation analysis in the MLH1 and MSH2 genes.RESULTSForty-three of 70 families (61%) presented with HNPCC Type II. In 21 of 30 families that had a complete genetic diagnosis, 16 pathogenic germline mutations (7 MLH1 mutations and 9 MSH2 mutations) and 5 mutations of unknown pathogenecity (all MLH1 mutations) were found. In the remaining nine families, no mutations were detected. Unequivocally pathogenic mutations were far more common in families with HNPCC Type II compared with families that had CRC only (P = 0.01). Families with endometrial carcinoma presented with the greatest probability of mutational detection (P = 0.005). MLH1 was only gene affected in families with HNPCC Type I, whereas mutations in both MLH1 and MSH2 were found in families with HNPCC Type II (P = 0.04). However, the MSH2 gene was more frequently involved in families with HNPCC in which endometrial carcinoma was present (P = 0.005).Forty-three of 70 families (61%) presented with HNPCC Type II. In 21 of 30 families that had a complete genetic diagnosis, 16 pathogenic germline mutations (7 MLH1 mutations and 9 MSH2 mutations) and 5 mutations of unknown pathogenecity (all MLH1 mutations) were found. In the remaining nine families, no mutations were detected. Unequivocally pathogenic mutations were far more common in families with HNPCC Type II compared with families that had CRC only (P = 0.01). Families with endometrial carcinoma presented with the greatest probability of mutational detection (P = 0.005). MLH1 was only gene affected in families with HNPCC Type I, whereas mutations in both MLH1 and MSH2 were found in families with HNPCC Type II (P = 0.04). However, the MSH2 gene was more frequently involved in families with HNPCC in which endometrial carcinoma was present (P = 0.005).CONCLUSIONSCRC and endometrial carcinoma were associated with a greater probability of detecting pathogenic mutations in mismatch repair genes, with MSH2 involvement predominating. The results support specific mutational screening strategies, based on observed phenotypes, for families with HNPCC. Cancer 2004. © 2004 American Cancer Society.CRC and endometrial carcinoma were associated with a greater probability of detecting pathogenic mutations in mismatch repair genes, with MSH2 involvement predominating. The results support specific mutational screening strategies, based on observed phenotypes, for families with HNPCC. Cancer 2004. © 2004 American Cancer Society.
    Download (.pdf)
    Hyperplastic polyposis (HP) is a rare condition characterized by the presence of multiple hyperplastic polyps in the colon, which has been associated to an increased risk of colorectal cancer (CRC). Guidelines for management of this... more
    Hyperplastic polyposis (HP) is a rare condition characterized by the presence of multiple hyperplastic polyps in the colon, which has been associated to an increased risk of colorectal cancer (CRC). Guidelines for management of this disease remain, so far, undefined. To evaluate, in symptomatic patients with HP, phenotypic characteristics as well as results of a screening program in their at-risk first-degree relatives. Pedigree information and clinical and endoscopic data of 14 patients with HP was studied. SEVENTEEN AND METHODS: at-risk first-degree relatives from six families were also invited to perform screening colonoscopy. Twelve of fourteen (86%) patients had fewer than 100 colorectal polyps. Polyps' sizes ranged from 2 to 25 mm and were uniformly distributed through the whole colon in 43% of the patients. Hyperplastic polyps predominated, but 11/14 (79%) patients also harbored serrated as well as classic adenomatous polyps. CRC was present in 6/14 (43%) of the patients at the time of diagnosis. Familial history of CRC/polyps was positive in 6/12 (50%) of cases. Colonoscopy in at-risk relatives disclosed polyps in 10/17 (59%) of cases with at least one additional patient having criteria for HP. Although small, this series demonstrates that a high level of suspicion is needed to diagnose the HP syndrome, in which serrated adenomas seem to be the hallmark. Although an elevated percentage of CRC was observed in this series of symptomatic patients with HP, prospective studies in asymptomatic individuals are needed to clearly quantify the risk of CRC in patients with HP. Because familial aggregation of HP was present in 3/12 (25%) of kindreds, screening colonoscopy should be offered to first-degree relatives.
    BACKGROUNDHereditary nonpolyposis colorectal carcinoma (HNPCC) significantly raises the risk of developing colorectal carcinoma (CRC) and other extracolonic tumors. It is defined by the Amsterdam Criteria and is associated with germline... more
    BACKGROUNDHereditary nonpolyposis colorectal carcinoma (HNPCC) significantly raises the risk of developing colorectal carcinoma (CRC) and other extracolonic tumors. It is defined by the Amsterdam Criteria and is associated with germline mutations in mismatch repair genes, primarily MLH1 and MSH2. The objectives of the current study were to evaluate the presence of CRC (Type I) and other extracolonic tumors (Type II) in families with HNPCC and to analyze the findings for correlations with germline mutations in the MLH1 and MSH2 genes.Hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal carcinoma (HNPCC) significantly raises the risk of developing colorectal carcinoma (CRC) and other extracolonic tumors. It is defined by the Amsterdam Criteria and is associated with germline mutations in mismatch repair genes, primarily MLH1 and MSH2. The objectives of the current study were to evaluate the presence of CRC (Type I) and other extracolonic tumors (Type II) in families with HNPCC and to analyze the findings for correlations with germline mutations in the MLH1 and MSH2 genes.METHODSSeventy families with an HNPCC diagnosis were analyzed. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis and direct sequencing were used for germline mutation analysis in the MLH1 and MSH2 genes.Seventy families with an HNPCC diagnosis were analyzed. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis and direct sequencing were used for germline mutation analysis in the MLH1 and MSH2 genes.RESULTSForty-three of 70 families (61%) presented with HNPCC Type II. In 21 of 30 families that had a complete genetic diagnosis, 16 pathogenic germline mutations (7 MLH1 mutations and 9 MSH2 mutations) and 5 mutations of unknown pathogenecity (all MLH1 mutations) were found. In the remaining nine families, no mutations were detected. Unequivocally pathogenic mutations were far more common in families with HNPCC Type II compared with families that had CRC only (P = 0.01). Families with endometrial carcinoma presented with the greatest probability of mutational detection (P = 0.005). MLH1 was only gene affected in families with HNPCC Type I, whereas mutations in both MLH1 and MSH2 were found in families with HNPCC Type II (P = 0.04). However, the MSH2 gene was more frequently involved in families with HNPCC in which endometrial carcinoma was present (P = 0.005).Forty-three of 70 families (61%) presented with HNPCC Type II. In 21 of 30 families that had a complete genetic diagnosis, 16 pathogenic germline mutations (7 MLH1 mutations and 9 MSH2 mutations) and 5 mutations of unknown pathogenecity (all MLH1 mutations) were found. In the remaining nine families, no mutations were detected. Unequivocally pathogenic mutations were far more common in families with HNPCC Type II compared with families that had CRC only (P = 0.01). Families with endometrial carcinoma presented with the greatest probability of mutational detection (P = 0.005). MLH1 was only gene affected in families with HNPCC Type I, whereas mutations in both MLH1 and MSH2 were found in families with HNPCC Type II (P = 0.04). However, the MSH2 gene was more frequently involved in families with HNPCC in which endometrial carcinoma was present (P = 0.005).CONCLUSIONSCRC and endometrial carcinoma were associated with a greater probability of detecting pathogenic mutations in mismatch repair genes, with MSH2 involvement predominating. The results support specific mutational screening strategies, based on observed phenotypes, for families with HNPCC. Cancer 2004. © 2004 American Cancer Society.CRC and endometrial carcinoma were associated with a greater probability of detecting pathogenic mutations in mismatch repair genes, with MSH2 involvement predominating. The results support specific mutational screening strategies, based on observed phenotypes, for families with HNPCC. Cancer 2004. © 2004 American Cancer Society.
    Download (.pdf)
    Hyperplastic polyposis (HP) is a rare condition characterized by the presence of multiple hyperplastic polyps in the colon, which has been associated to an increased risk of colorectal cancer (CRC). Guidelines for management of this... more
    Hyperplastic polyposis (HP) is a rare condition characterized by the presence of multiple hyperplastic polyps in the colon, which has been associated to an increased risk of colorectal cancer (CRC). Guidelines for management of this disease remain, so far, undefined. To evaluate, in symptomatic patients with HP, phenotypic characteristics as well as results of a screening program in their at-risk first-degree relatives. Pedigree information and clinical and endoscopic data of 14 patients with HP was studied. SEVENTEEN AND METHODS: at-risk first-degree relatives from six families were also invited to perform screening colonoscopy. Twelve of fourteen (86%) patients had fewer than 100 colorectal polyps. Polyps' sizes ranged from 2 to 25 mm and were uniformly distributed through the whole colon in 43% of the patients. Hyperplastic polyps predominated, but 11/14 (79%) patients also harbored serrated as well as classic adenomatous polyps. CRC was present in 6/14 (43%) of the patients at the time of diagnosis. Familial history of CRC/polyps was positive in 6/12 (50%) of cases. Colonoscopy in at-risk relatives disclosed polyps in 10/17 (59%) of cases with at least one additional patient having criteria for HP. Although small, this series demonstrates that a high level of suspicion is needed to diagnose the HP syndrome, in which serrated adenomas seem to be the hallmark. Although an elevated percentage of CRC was observed in this series of symptomatic patients with HP, prospective studies in asymptomatic individuals are needed to clearly quantify the risk of CRC in patients with HP. Because familial aggregation of HP was present in 3/12 (25%) of kindreds, screening colonoscopy should be offered to first-degree relatives.
    225 editorial sistenciais concretos, donde resulta que as expectativas de controlo e previsibilidade dos modelos e dos crité-rios inovadores de gestão só poderão ser viáveis se le-varem em linha de conta a sua implementação na rea-lidade... more
    225 editorial sistenciais concretos, donde resulta que as expectativas de controlo e previsibilidade dos modelos e dos crité-rios inovadores de gestão só poderão ser viáveis se le-varem em linha de conta a sua implementação na rea-lidade específica dos contextos profissionais. Nesta medida, e como consequência, qualquer es-forço mais voluntarista de tomar como previsíveis os re-sultados dos processos de racionalização e de padro-nização no mundo dos profissionais e das organiza-ções onde estes operam terá sempre o seu sucesso con-dicionado se não for capaz de integrar um esforço de compreensão desses mesmos contextos e das práticas profissionais dos seus respectivos intervenientes. É jus-tamente por esta razão que é oportuno reconhecer a pertinência e a utilidade das abordagens da investiga-ção qualitativa de áreas como as ciências sociais, dado que as suas potencialidades analíticas podem concor-rer para a compreensão de aspectos tão significativos como a reflexividade profissional...
    Download (.pdf)
    Resumo: Tendo como base o contributo inovador de Fleck para o estudo do conhecimento médico, procura-se neste artigo explorar a ideia da incomensurabilidade entre estilos de pensamento. O objetivo principal é o de discutir em que medida... more
    Resumo: Tendo como base o contributo inovador de Fleck para o estudo do conhecimento médico, procura-se neste artigo explorar a ideia da incomensurabilidade entre estilos de pensamento. O objetivo principal é o de discutir em que medida as recentes reconfigurações suscitadas pela consolidação da Medicina Baseada na Evidência se têm traduzido na reformulação dos fundamentos da prática clínica. A partir da ilustração exploratória da especialidade de Medicina Geral e Familiar, sustenta-se que o contexto da praxis clínica implica articulações compósitas entre diferentes estilos de pensamento. Daí resulta que em lugar do conceito de incomensurabilidade, poderá ser mais adequado aprofundar as potencialidades da ideia de sincretismo epistemológico. Palavras-chave: Incomensurabilidade; Estilos de Pensamento; Medicina Baseada na Evidência; Sincretismo Epistemológico. Abstract: On the basis of Fleck’s innovative contribution to the study of medical knowledge, this article seeks to explore the...
    Download (.pdf)
    The present article is the result of a sociological investigation project on the medical uncertainties in the context of the genetic counseling in the area of the hereditary cancer. Having as groundwork a case study developed in the scope... more
    The present article is the result of a sociological investigation project on the medical uncertainties in the context of the genetic counseling in the area of the hereditary cancer. Having as groundwork a case study developed in the scope of a family risk assessment in an oncologic hospital unit, the aim is to identify and analyze the new uncertainty dimensions emerging from this specific clinical context and highlight the way how these redefine the work practices as well as the clinical judgments. The analytical framework which organizes the sociological approaches about these new uncertainties is developed from the examination of two favoured axes related to the scientific profile of this biomedical area. The reconfiguration of the illness and medicine conception and the paradoxes of its predictive logic
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)
    A biomedicina é um domínio do saber no qual a proliferação do conceito de risco se tem evidenciado de forma expressiva, o que revela uma preocupação em proceder ao controlo sistemático dos problemas através de um modelo de racionalização... more
    A biomedicina é um domínio do saber no qual a proliferação do conceito de risco se tem evidenciado de forma expressiva, o que revela uma preocupação em proceder ao controlo sistemático dos problemas através de um modelo de racionalização instru-mental. Tal procedimento é ...
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)
    Resumo (ID: 560) O desenvolvimento da medicina moderna é cada vez mais indissociável das tecnologias e da sua crescente inovação. O seu uso constitui um elemento integrante e indispensável na prática médica, a ponto da sua incorporação... more
    Resumo (ID: 560) O desenvolvimento da medicina moderna é cada vez mais indissociável das tecnologias e da sua crescente inovação. O seu uso constitui um elemento integrante e indispensável na prática médica, a ponto da sua incorporação ser projectada como um sinal de avanço neste campo científico. De resto, o modo como as novas tecnologias vão sendo desenvolvidas e aplicadas à prática médica tende a ser entendido como algo de benéfico e naturalmente irrecusável para a saúde humana. Contudo, o que um olhar menos triunfalista sobre o valor intrínseco das tecnologias nos pode ajudar a desocultar é o facto de que as inovações contemporâneas não estão simplesmente a estender o repertório médico, mas estão também a transformar a própria medicina. Estas inovações estão a mudar a nossa compreensão da doença e da saúde, redefinindo os conceitos de doença, de medicina e de corpo. Com efeito, os conceitos de saúde e de estilo de vida encontram-se cada vez mais ancorados na ideia de um corpo sa...
    Neste artigo identificam-se os padrões de consumo terapêutico na população portuguesa, visando dar conta de um novo padrão emergente nas sociedades modernas, aqui designado de Pluralismo Terapêutico, noção com a qual se categoriza o uso... more
    Neste artigo identificam-se os padrões de consumo terapêutico na população portuguesa, visando dar conta de um novo padrão emergente nas sociedades modernas, aqui designado de Pluralismo Terapêutico, noção com a qual se categoriza o uso conjugado ou alternado de recursos farmacológicos e naturais nas trajetórias terapêuticas dos indivíduos. O respetivo suporte empírico decorre de uma investigação, já concluída, que teve por base uma amostra nacional representativa. Os resultados mostram uma dualiza- ção dos consumos terapêuticos que é constituída por um padrão dominante de Farmacologismo – i.e., uso exclusivo de fármacos – coexistente com uma tendência crescente de pluralismo terapêutico. O efeito das fontes de informação terapêutica e dos seus usos leigos, bem como das perceções sociais de risco sobre o natural e o farmacológico, constitui neste estudo uma referência analítica central para a interpretação dos padrões encontrados.
    Research Interests:
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)
    This article analyses performance consumptions among young people. The theme is explored along two main axes. The first concerns the social heterogeneity in this field, considered on two levels: the different purposes for those... more
    This article analyses performance consumptions among young people. The theme is explored along two main axes. The first concerns the social heterogeneity in this field, considered on two levels: the different purposes for those investments - cognitive/mental and physical performance; and the different social contexts - university and work - where performance practices and dispositions may be fostered. The second axis explores the roles of pharmacological and natural consumptions, and their interrelationship, in the dissemination of these practices. The empirical data for this analysis were drawn from an ongoing research project on performance consumptions among young people (aged 18-29 years) in Portugal, including both university students and young workers without university education. The results correspond to the stage of extensive research, for which a questionnaire was organised at a national level, using non-proportional quota sampling. On the one hand, they show that (a) ther...
    Hyperplastic polyposis (HP) is a rare condition characterized by the presence of multiple hyperplastic polyps in the colon, which has been associated to an increased risk of colorectal cancer (CRC). Guidelines for management of this... more
    Hyperplastic polyposis (HP) is a rare condition characterized by the presence of multiple hyperplastic polyps in the colon, which has been associated to an increased risk of colorectal cancer (CRC). Guidelines for management of this disease remain, so far, undefined. To evaluate, in symptomatic patients with HP, phenotypic characteristics as well as results of a screening program in their at-risk first-degree relatives. Pedigree information and clinical and endoscopic data of 14 patients with HP was studied. SEVENTEEN AND METHODS: at-risk first-degree relatives from six families were also invited to perform screening colonoscopy. Twelve of fourteen (86%) patients had fewer than 100 colorectal polyps. Polyps' sizes ranged from 2 to 25 mm and were uniformly distributed through the whole colon in 43% of the patients. Hyperplastic polyps predominated, but 11/14 (79%) patients also harbored serrated as well as classic adenomatous polyps. CRC was present in 6/14 (43%) of the patients at the time of diagnosis. Familial history of CRC/polyps was positive in 6/12 (50%) of cases. Colonoscopy in at-risk relatives disclosed polyps in 10/17 (59%) of cases with at least one additional patient having criteria for HP. Although small, this series demonstrates that a high level of suspicion is needed to diagnose the HP syndrome, in which serrated adenomas seem to be the hallmark. Although an elevated percentage of CRC was observed in this series of symptomatic patients with HP, prospective studies in asymptomatic individuals are needed to clearly quantify the risk of CRC in patients with HP. Because familial aggregation of HP was present in 3/12 (25%) of kindreds, screening colonoscopy should be offered to first-degree relatives.
    Abstract: The current role that dietary supplements have been playing under new logic of supply and consumption of therapeutic resources, is a fact that reveals the emergence of new phenomena that generate major reconfigurations to the... more
    Abstract: The current role that dietary supplements have been playing under new logic of supply and consumption of therapeutic resources, is a fact that reveals the emergence of new phenomena that generate major reconfigurations to the social dimension of new ...
    Download (.pdf)
    Download (.pdf)